×
Search

866-540-5505

Se Habla Espanol
Menu
Search

Our Blog

Home/Blog/New England Energy Provider Cannot Preclude a Jury Trial

New England Energy Provider Cannot Preclude a Jury Trial

On December 7, 2022, United States District Judge Janet C. Hall of the District of Connecticut partially denied the Motion to Strike Plaintiffs’ Jury Demand (“Motion”) filed by New England energy provider Eversource Energy Company (“Eversource”), the Board of Directors of Eversource Energy Company (“Board”), the Eversource Plan Administrative Committee (“Administrative Committee”), the Eversource Investment Management Committee (“Investment Committee,” and, with the Administrative Committee, “Committees”), and named members of the Board and the Committees (collectively, “Defendants”), finding that Defendants cannot preclude a jury trial against 11,000 former and current participants (the “Class” or “Plaintiffs”) in the Eversource 401(k) Plan (“the Plan”).

Plaintiffs sued under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”), a regulatory labor law that establishes standards of prudence and loyalty for retirement and health plan administrators to protect enrolled individuals and their beneficiaries. Under ERISA, plan administrators, trustees, and investment committees named as fiduciaries must act for the exclusive benefit of participants, choose prudent and diverse investment options to offer through a plan, and ensure that plan expenses are fair and reasonable.

Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint filed in October 2022 called for a trial by jury for all claims. In May 2022, the court certified the Class as participants and beneficiaries in the Plan on or after June 30, 2022. In July 2022, Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment and three motions to preclude expert testimony were all denied in full.

The Class, represented by Miller Shah LLP, alleged that Defendants breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA by retaining high-cost and poor-performing investment options in the Plan instead of readily available better-performing alternatives, failing to disclose the risks and expenses of those investment options, and allowing Plan participants to pay recordkeeping and administrative fees that were excessive relative to the services the Plan received and true administrative costs.

Defendants’ Memorandum of Law in Support of their Motion, filed in August 2022, argued that neither ERISA nor the Seventh Amendment provide a right to a jury trial for fiduciary breach claims. Opposing Defendants’ argument, Plaintiffs pointed out that they sought relief from Defendants’ general assets, an amount that must be determined by a jury.

In considering the Motion, the Court “examine[d] the remedy sought and determine[d] whether it is legal or equitable in nature.” The Court held that because the damages Plaintiffs requested were “the restoration of losses to the Plan—requested in [multiple] Counts—[awarded damages] would not be equitable restitution as the Defendants are not alleged to have possessed those funds.” Therefore, Judge Hall concluded that a jury could deliberate on some of Plaintiffs’ requests for relief.

The parties are currently preparing for a jury trial, which is set to begin on April 4, 2023 and estimated to last between 11 and 13 days.

The case caption for this matter is Garthwait et al. v. Eversource Energy Service Co. et al., No. 3:20-CV-00902-JCH, filed in the District of Connecticut.

The legal team at Miller Shah LLP has significant experience representing ERISA matters. If you have any questions regarding this subject or this post, please contact Alec Berin (ajberin@millershah.com) or Jonathan Dilger (jadilger@millershah.com). The firm can also be reached toll-free at (866) 540-5505.

Share Post:
facebooktwitterLinkedin

Categories

Archives

Contact
Miller Shah LLP

While this website provides general information, it does not constitute legal advice. The best way to get guidance on your specific legal issue is to contact a lawyer. To schedule a meeting with an attorney, please call 866-540-5505 or complete the intake form to email us.
Alec J. Berin - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Alfonso Vilaboa - Of Counsel

NJ Hoboken |

Anika S. Keuning - Project Analyst

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Anna D’Agostino - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Betsy Ferling-Hitriz - Legal Assistant

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Bruce D. Parke - Partners

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Caroline Soper - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Christopher A. Miller - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Deborah C. England - Of Counsel

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Edward H. Glenn - Of Counsel

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Edward M. Fitzgerald - Staff Attorney

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

Elena M. DiBattista - Legal Assistant

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Elise M. Wilson - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Eric L. Young - Of Counsel

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Finn M. Mutrux - Office Staff

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

Gina S. Demetriades - Office Staff

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Heidi A. Wendel - Of Counsel

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

James C. Shah - Partners

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

James E. Miller - Partners

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Jayne A. Goldstein - Partners

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Jillian M. Boyce - Office Staff

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Jocelyn McNamara - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Johanna C. Richter - Law Clerk

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

John C. Roberts - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Jonathan Dilger - Office Staff

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Julie M. Capito - Legal Assistant

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Katie Edwards - Legal Assistant

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Kolin C. Tang - Partners

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Laurie Rubinow - Partners

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Madison Gregg - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Marialisa Samo - Legal Assistant

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Mark Xiao - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Natalie Finkelman Bennett - Partners

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Nathan C. Zipperian - Partners

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Nicholas Day - Of Counsel

NJ Hoboken | 866-540-5505

Nicholas K. Ono - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Raffaele Scalcione - Of Counsel

IT Milan | 866-540-5505

Reilly K. Powers - Project Analyst

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Robert W. Biela - Staff Attorney

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Ronald S. Kravitz - Of Counsel

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Rrita Osmani - Project Analyst

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Shuping Li - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Stephen T. Rutkowski - Law Clerk

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Sue Moss - Legal Assistant

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Sydney D. Finlay - Associate

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Tina Moukoulis - Staff Attorney

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505