×
Search

866-540-5505

Se Habla Espanol
Menu
Search

Our Blog

Home/Blog/Sutter Health ERISA Plaintiffs Overcome Motion to Dismiss

Sutter Health ERISA Plaintiffs Overcome Motion to Dismiss

On February 9, 2023, the Honorable Jennifer L. Thurston of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California determined that class action claims alleging breaches of fiduciary duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (“ERISA”) survived the motion to dismiss filed by Sutter Health and the Retirement Benefits Investment Committee of Sutter Health (together, “Defendants”). 

ERISA is a federal statute that protects workers by establishing standards, known as fiduciary duties, to ensure that investments offered to employees participating in defined contribution retirement plans are prudently and loyally selected and monitored.  

Sutter Health is the plan sponsor of the Sutter Health 403(b) Savings Plan (the “Plan”). As of December 31, 2018, the Plan had 73,408 participants and assets totaling $3.7 billion, placing it in the top 0.1% of all defined contribution retirement plans by size. The Plan’s large size gives it enhanced bargaining power and leverage to demand lower plan administration fees.

Plaintiffs, Christina Bonicarlo, Nicole Garcia, Ronald Hudson, Adam Blackburn, Robert L. Hackett, Tabitha Hoglund, and Stephanie Chadwick (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) allege that Defendants breached their fiduciary duties of prudence and loyalty under ERISA by retaining underperforming funds with excessive fees, instead of offering less expensive, readily available prudent alternative investments.  Specifically, Plaintiffs assert Defendants were imprudent in offering the Fidelity Freedom Funds target date series, the Parnassus Core Equity Fund, the Dodge & Cox Stock Fund, and the Lazard Emerging Markers Equity Fund.  Plaintiffs also argue that Plan participants paid excessive recordkeeping and administrative fees and the Plan’s total plan cost was too high.

Judge Thurston upheld Plaintiffs’ duty of prudence claim, finding that Plaintiffs’ allegations concerning the challenged investments’ comparative underperformance, capital flight, and investment industry criticism were sufficient to infer a flawed fiduciary process.  Judge Thurston further held that the Complaint’s comparison of the Plan to similar sized plans being charged much lower per-participant administrative fees sufficiently stated claims regarding the Plan’s recordkeeping and total plan cost.

As to the fiduciary duty of loyalty, the Court found it could infer breach because Plaintiffs alleged that the high investment management fees the Plan paid to Fidelity could have contributed to Defendants’ retention of the challenged investments in the Plan.

Furthermore, although Defendants argued that Plaintiffs lack standing to sue because they did not plead that they were invested in the specific funds named in the complaint, Judge Thurston held that, because the allegations speak to “Defendants’ management of the Plan as a whole…Plaintiffs need not plead their individual investment in any particular fund so long as the fees challenged were charged to all plan participants regardless of participants’ specific investments.”

The proposed Class includes Plaintiffs and all similarly situated participants and beneficiaries in the Plan. The proposed Class is represented by Miller Shah LLP, Capozzi Adler, P.C., and Rosman & Germain APC.

The case is In re Sutter Health ERISA Litigation., number 1:20-cv-01007-JLT, filed in the Eastern District of California.

The legal team at Miller Shah LLP has extensive experience with class action matters. If you have any questions regarding this subject or this post, please contact Alec Berin (ajberin@millershah.com) or Jonathan Dilger (jadilger@millershah.com). The Firm can also be reached toll-free at (866) 540-5505.

Share Post:
facebooktwitterLinkedin

Categories

Archives

Contact
Miller Shah LLP

While this website provides general information, it does not constitute legal advice. The best way to get guidance on your specific legal issue is to contact a lawyer. To schedule a meeting with an attorney, please call 866-540-5505 or complete the intake form to email us.
Alec J. Berin - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Alfonso Vilaboa - Of Counsel

NJ Hoboken |

Anika S. Keuning - Project Analyst

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Anna D’Agostino - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Betsy Ferling-Hitriz - Legal Assistant

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Bruce D. Parke - Partners

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Caroline Soper - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Christopher A. Miller - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Deborah C. England - Of Counsel

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Edward H. Glenn - Of Counsel

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Edward M. Fitzgerald - Staff Attorney

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

Elena M. DiBattista - Legal Assistant

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Elise M. Wilson - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Eric L. Young - Of Counsel

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Finn M. Mutrux - Office Staff

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

Gina S. Demetriades - Office Staff

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Heidi A. Wendel - Of Counsel

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

James C. Shah - Partners

CA Los Angeles | 866-540-5505

James E. Miller - Partners

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Jayne A. Goldstein - Partners

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Jillian M. Boyce - Office Staff

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Jocelyn McNamara - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Johanna C. Richter - Law Clerk

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

John C. Roberts - Associate

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Jonathan Dilger - Office Staff

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Julie M. Capito - Legal Assistant

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Katie Edwards - Legal Assistant

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Kolin C. Tang - Partners

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Laurie Rubinow - Partners

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Madison Gregg - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Marialisa Samo - Legal Assistant

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Mark Xiao - Associate

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Natalie Finkelman Bennett - Partners

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Nathan C. Zipperian - Partners

FL Fort Lauderdale | 866-540-5505

Nicholas Day - Of Counsel

NJ Hoboken | 866-540-5505

Nicholas K. Ono - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Raffaele Scalcione - Of Counsel

IT Milan | 866-540-5505

Reilly K. Powers - Project Analyst

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Robert W. Biela - Staff Attorney

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Ronald S. Kravitz - Of Counsel

CA San Francisco | 866-540-5505

Rrita Osmani - Project Analyst

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Shuping Li - Project Analyst

NY New York City | 866-540-5505

Stephen T. Rutkowski - Law Clerk

CT Chester | 866-540-5505

Sue Moss - Legal Assistant

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505

Sydney D. Finlay - Associate

CA San Diego | 866-540-5505

Tina Moukoulis - Staff Attorney

PA Philadelphia | 866-540-5505